New draft crop, same daunting environment and familiar curly questions.
From burning houses and broken televisions to a $900,000 hypothetical and an AFL club determined to test one prospect’s resolve, draft hopefuls have faced some curious challenges off the field this year.
Watch every match of AFLW LIVE and ad-break free during play on FOX FOOTY, available on Kayo Sports.
One question seemed to follow this year’s draft prospects: If their house was burning down, which three items would they grab before leaving?
WHAT’S GAMBLING REALLY COSTING YOU? Set a deposit limit. For Free and confidential support call 1800 858 858 or visit gamblinghelponline.org.au.
GWV Rebels on-baller Ethan Drever said: “My phone, a footy and my headphones.”
Western Jets small forward Khaled El Souki said: “My phone, my PlayStation and shoes.”
Geelong Falcons key forward Jack Pickett said: “My golf clubs, my phone and a laptop – I was a bit torn for the last one!”
Northern Knights ruck Harry Van Hattum said: “My phone, my passport and a signed Luke Hodge jersey.”
Gippsland Power goalkicker Wil Malady said: “My footy boots, a footy and a pillow.”
Malady’s Power teammate Clancy Snell said: “My phone, a footy and my dog … I definitely wouldn’t take a footy, but I just said it to impress them!”
Several prospects identified Carlton as the club that posed the question.
But it wasn’t the only question from the Blues that caught some prospects off-guard.
“Carlton asked me: ‘How do you retain information?’” Woodville-West Torrens forward Jack Slattery told foxfooty.com.au.
“I was just like: ‘Probably revise, maybe?’ That’s what I do for school, but I don’t know about footy!”
Claremont midfielder-defender Heath Mellody claimed “Carlton asked some random questions about superpowers” during last year’s AFL Academy trip to New Zealand, while Northern Knights key forward Sam Gayfer said the Blues “asked me whether my room was clean”.
“That was a strange one to be hit with pretty early on,” Gayfer told foxfooty.com.au.
“I told them the truth. It wasn’t.”
Sandringham Dragons forward-midfielder Gus Teixeira, who conceded he was “not that good in a face-to-face interview setting but I’m improving”, said one club asked if he had a kid.
“That was pretty funny. I just started laughing,” Teixeira told foxfooty.com.au.
Some questions were more confronting than others.
AFLW Lions Academy midfielder Molly Ferguson was asked which player she would delist from a club’s list, while Gippsland Power small forward Marlon Neocleous was asked to reveal the worst thing he’d ever done.
“I didn’t really have an answer at first, but then said I smashed the TV with a Wii remote when I was playing Wii Tennis,” Neocleous told foxfooty.com.au.
For some prospects, the toughest questions were those that forced them to talk themselves up – or put other players down.
“I’m not a massive fan of the ones where you’ve got to talk about yourself,” Sandringham Dragons forward-midfielder Arki Butler told foxfooty.com.au.
“The ones that are like: ‘Why should we draft you?’ Or a couple of teams at the top have sort of said: ‘Why should we take you with our first pick?’ It’s hard to talk yourself up in one of those situations.”
Pick 1 AFLW draft contender Cara Dziegielewski added: “I just don’t like talking about myself so much, so when they ask, ‘Why are you better than so-and-so?’, I’m like, ‘Aw, sorry, I don’t know.’”
Perhaps the most niche question was asked of Giants academy midfielder Ethan Matthews, who captained the Allies in this year’s Under 18 national championships.
“Adelaide asked me how I’d invest $900,000 into the Allies program over three periods … I was a bit shocked at it, to be honest,” Matthews told foxfooty.com.au. “Luckily, Dad’s engineering side had prepared me a little for a curveball.
“They broke it into three blocks and said I had $300,000 for each.
“At first, I said I’d invest it in getting the Allies boys together a bit more and having a training program. But then I was a bit stumped and basically said the same thing three times.”
‘Compromised’ draft to cause chaos? | 05:44
Swans academy prospect Mason McGroder had just come from an interview with the Western Bulldogs at the MCG before speaking to foxfooty.com.au.
McGroder said he told those in the room he was “very optimistic and ambitious” about his footy future and that he wanted to play AFL games in 2027.
It prompted an interesting exchange.
“Then they asked: ‘OK, so for argument’s sake, if you don’t make your debut by Round 9, what would you do?’ I said I’d just go back to work, try to get better and get in the team,” McGroder told foxfooty.com.au.
“Then they kept going and going until Round 20. I was like: ‘Yeah, honestly, just the same.’
“You can tell when the interviewers are trying to get you to crack basically under the pressure.”
McGroder has spent the year weighing up two very different sporting ambitions: Pursuing an athletics career that could take him to the Brisbane 2032 Olympics or testing himself against the best in the AFL.
McGroder said “10 to 15” US colleges this year had reached out – primarily through his parents and athletics coach – about the prospect of moving to America to significantly enhance his athletics career. But interest from AFL teams has increased throughout the year, with nine interviews with McGroder scheduled for the combine.
Asked whether his meetings with colleges or AFL clubs had been more intimidating, McGroder said: “Definitely the AFL clubs.
“The college chats are basically them trying to entice me to come, whereas it’s almost vice versa for the AFL clubs where I have to express why I think I’d be the best fit for them.
“At the end of the day, I don’t really get a choice with footy. With college, I could go anywhere in America.”
The combine interviews can be a more intense experience than the home visits and Zoom calls prospects have throughout the year.
Clubs set up in corporate boxes around the MCG, with players moving between scheduled meetings and sometimes facing a room full of recruiters and senior coaches.
“It’s pretty full-on but a really cool experience … 14 or 15 in-person interviews here (at the combine) over a couple of days,” Van Hattum said.
Neocleous said he enjoyed speaking with Carlton’s new boss Josh Fraser, while Drever said Giants coach Adam Kingsley “puts you on the spot once or twice” but was “a good bloke”. Other AFL coaches who attended included Richmond’s Adem Yze, Essendon’s Mark McVeigh and Port Adelaide’s Josh Carr, while Carlton’s Matthew Buck was one of several AFLW coaches spotted at the AFLW combine.
Top Swans AFLW academy prospect Charlotte Tidemann was left starstruck when she came face-to-face with an Australian Football Hall of Fame member.
“I just walked into the Gold Coast room with (Suns women’s football boss) Erin Phillips and that was very cool,” Tidemann told foxfooty.com.au.
“I was sitting across from her and she’s having a normal conversation like she knows who I am. And I’m like: ‘Do you know who you are?! You’re Erin Phillips, I’m just me.’”
Draft prospects often note the increase in intensity – and volume of club representatives – during interviews at the combine, compared to the Zoom chats or home visits they experience throughout the year.
Van Hattum said his family put on food and drinks for his first few home visits from AFL clubs, but the effort didn’t last long.
“At the start, we definitely brought some sushi platters, drinks and coffees,” he said.
“But after the eighth or ninth one, we were just like: ‘We’re getting sick of this.’ So we just put out jugs of water and that’s about it now.”
Despite being tied to the Brisbane Lions’ academy, young gun defender Caylen Murray said a couple of clubs had visited his house.
“It’s a bit daunting,” Murray told foxfooty.com.au.
“The Dees walked around my kitchen a little bit, looking at my fridge and all that sort of stuff.”
Pickett spent much of 2026 sidelined by injury, using the time away from football to prepare for the interview process.
But one club still managed to throw him a curveball.
“I got a bit of vision of me – I had to talk them through that – then also a bit from an AFL player from their team,” he said.
Asked if the vision of him was presented in a positive or negative light, Pickett said: “I’d say both. There was one that I did well and had to analyse that, and then there was one where I probably could have done something a bit differently. I had to talk about what I would have done instead.”
North Adelaide ruck-forward Ethan Herbert, who claimed “people would be lying if they said they don’t go into an interview nervous”, had a similar experience to Pickett.
“I think Collingwood put some vision up. I feel like I’ve heard a lot of the other boys say some recruiters have got some vision up of AFL games and what you would do in this situation,” Herbert told foxfooty.com.au.
For top-10 prospect Butler, the key is to embrace the process. Clubs ultimately want to get to know the person behind the player.
“It’s pretty different to anything I’ve ever experienced before,” Butler said.
“If they like you for who you are and if you’re lucky enough to get drafted by them, then how awesome is that?”
Perhaps Swan Districts midfielder Leo Steed had the best advice for any aspiring AFL and AFLW footballers.
“I’ve kind of found just to enjoy the experience,” Steed told foxfooty.com.au.
“You’ve worked your whole life for this. Just really enjoy it and be yourself.”

Leave a Reply