Reservoir Suno lawsuit

Photo Credit: Planet Volumes

Another log on the litigation fire: Suno is now facing a nearly $200 million copyright infringement and DMCA complaint from Reservoir Media, which has also fired off a similar action against Anthropic.

Richard S. Busch-repped Reservoir submitted both suits to the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, with Suno and Anthropic (not their execs) named as defendants.

For those who’ve been following the avalanche of infringement litigation against AI giants – and particularly Suno, which is grappling with more than a few complaints – the claims will sound familiar.

In Reservoir’s view, Suno trained on a pile of protected music without authorization and, by inking licensing pacts with Warner Music, BMG, Believe, and others, “all but admitted that there is a functioning market for licensing music and sound recordings for training data.”

“Suno never sought or obtained a license from Reservoir to reproduce, copy, or train on any particular composition or sound recording in Reservoir’s catalog, much less for all of its Works. Suno’s training-data practices constitute direct copyright infringement on a massive scale,” the legal text spells out.

Suno’s soundalike guardrails aside, Reservoir is calling out the alleged ability to harness straightforward workarounds en route to generating unauthorized outputs resembling proper artists’ music.

And there’s “evidence that users can easily create unlicensed derivative works merely by submitting them themselves,” per Reservoir. Under its terms, Suno can then purportedly “take these user submissions and further train its models on them despite the guardrails.”

Notably, the above-highlighted stack of cases against Suno also factors into Reservoir’s litigation, which cites details from separate actions spearheaded by Universal Music, Round Hill Music, and, in Germany, GEMA.

Likewise part of the suit: Alleged data-scraper Bright Data, which is named as a defendant in Round Hill’s Suno complaint (the plaintiff is repped by Busch as well) but is a non-party here.

Nevertheless, Suno allegedly used the Israel-based entity’s “services to scrape and incorporate into its training data files like ‘youtube_music’ which includes over two million music clips of approximately 113,879 hours—the equivalent of thirteen years—of music files scraped from YouTube.”

Meanwhile, Reservoir is adamant that Suno’s alleged conduct doesn’t constitute fair use – “(b)uilding and maintaining a permanent stockpile of copyrighted material for open-ended future exploitation fails every factor of the fair-use analysis,” per the plaintiff.

Regarding damages, the filing party is seeking the statutory maximum of $150,000 a pop for 1,050 allegedly willfully infringed works, or $157.5 million.

On top of that sum, Reservoir is demanding relief for alleged DMCA violations, referring specifically to $2.63 million for the alleged circumvention of access controls and an additional $26.25 million for the alleged removal of copyright management information (CMI).

The complaint against Anthropic alleges the same claims – willful direct infringement as well as the circumvention of access controls and the removal of CMI – for 853 works. And like the Suno action, the suit capitalizes on the growing collection of publicly available AI training information, referring in large part to The Atlantic’s AI Watchdog dataset-search tool.

All told, Reservoir is pushing to receive $127.95 million for Anthropic’s alleged infringement (“Claude has created infringing output for all 853 of the Works, and likely every song in Reservoir’s catalog”) plus another $23.5 million on the DMCA side.

A possible legal bill exceeding $150 million is, of course, nothing to scoff at. But for multiple reasons – and not solely the Claude developer’s even larger valuation and reach – it’s Suno that appears to be in the more precarious spot.

Despite boasting several significant partnerships – and having swapped its prior models for newly trained v6 offerings – the music generator is currently staring down litigation from the non-Warner majors, Gerencia 360, Round Hill, Denmark’s KODA, indie artists including Tony Justice, Canada’s SOCAN, David Lowery, and others yet.





–