UMG v Suno

Photo Credit: Radission US

One UMG v. Suno subpoena dispute down, many more to go: Universal Music and Sony Music have withdrawn their motion to compel DistroKid to turn over a trove of documents concerning its AI-audio distribution volume.

The non-Warner majors finalized that resolution in a brief notice after closing October by confirming ongoing talks with DistroKid. And as we broke down in detail then, the underlying non-party subpoena showdown – not to be confused with Universal Music’s separate suit accusing the distributor of “flooding platforms with AI-generated ‘slop’” – kicked off in September.

Long story short, following a good bit of back and forth, Universal Music and Sony Music demanded documents pertaining to how many DistroKid uploads a third-party “prediction model” had identified as likely AI-generated and, additionally, pumped out via Suno; who developed said model; and the uploads’ royalties.

Fast forward to October 27th, when the relevant parties said they were “working on a resolution,” and once more to today’s notice, wherein the non-Warner majors formally shelved the motion to compel compliance with the subpoena.

Though the filing is light on particulars, it does note that “DistroKid has served supplemental responses and produced documents responsive” to the above-highlighted requests. With that, the majors asked the court to terminate the proceeding at hand.

Time will tell whether the disclosure encompasses information that could support the plaintiffs’ market-dilution and -replacement claims. Similarly, it remains to be seen how the convoluted legal battle’s other aforementioned subpoena clashes will unfold.

As for where the confrontations stand, Universal Music and Sony Music are evidently on a different page than Suno investor Menlo Ventures. Last week, the movants sought a late-November Zoom hearing on their motion to compel while acknowledging Menlo’s opposition and belief “‘that the issues can be decided on the papers.’”

Next, both the Suno v. MLC motion to compel and the Apple v. Suno motion to quash are still playing out. Against this backdrop, it probably goes without saying that the overarching case – meaning Universal Music’s and Sony Music’s 2024 infringement complaint against Suno – isn’t progressing at a breakneck pace.

On the contrary, the AI music platform and the majors also disagree about whether the second Suno suit (filed in September) should be paused as the first proceeds. When seeking only a “partial” discovery stay in UMG v. Suno II, Universal Music and Sony Music indicated that the older case “could realistically extend into 2028.”

That is, of course, a long way out – especially when considered alongside the rapid evolution of the unprecedented technology and the wider AI landscape.

Speaking of this quick-changing landscape, Suno’s artist-specific offerings, the overhauled Udio, and Spotify’s AI remix tool are expected to arrive in the near future – with products including ElevenLabs’ and Universal Music’s “new AI-powered music creation platform” on the horizon as well.





–