By Gerald Bourguet
We knew the Phoenix Suns’ bench would be one of their greatest strengths. We also figured the fit of the starting lineup would be a concern. But 13 games into the season, it’s hard to imagine anyone saw the contrast between the two being this dire.
Make no mistake about it: The Suns’ starting lineup has been one of the worst starting units in the entire NBA, and right now, they’re being propped up by one of the league’s best benches.
As the name implies, we have to start with the starters. It’s been amusing to watch Suns fans debate whether Oso Ighodaro or Khaman Maluach should start at center, since their 5 will be a flawed backup either way. Phoenix is 5-2 with Ighodaro starting, compared to 1-5 with Maluach starting, and Man Man’s trial by fire felt like too much too soon, but either way, the Suns’ starters have floundered.
The starting lineup with Oso Ighodaro at the 5 is a -41 in 96 minutes over nine games together, which is the second-worst total point differential in the NBA among all five-man lineups, trailing only the Sacramento Kings’ disaster-class of Darius Acuff Jr., Zach LaVine, De’Andre Hunter, Precious Achiuwa and Domantas Sabonis.
Replace Ighodaro with Maluach and it doesn’t get much better. The Suns were a -29 in 79 minutes over eight games with Man Man in the starting lineup, which is the fifth-worst total point differential among all five-man lineups in the league — right behind abhorrent lineups from the lowly Chicago Bulls and Utah Jazz.
That’s a problem — and a recurring uphill battle — when only one other five-man lineup in Phoenix has cracked at least 20 minutes this season, compared to 96 and 79 for both failing starting units!
The starters with Ighodaro have a -23.6 Net Rating; the starters with Maluach have a -20.0 Net Rating. It’s been awful regardless of which center gets the starting nod, and the common denominator is the fit of the other four guys.
That four-man grouping of Devin Booker, Jalen Green, Dillon Brooks and Miles Bridges is now a -91 in 195 minutestogether. That’s the worst total point differential among 2,000 different four-man lineup combinations across the league. Even if you narrow it down to 282 four-man lineups who have played at least 50 minutes together, or 91 four-man combos that have logged at least 100 minutes together, the Suns’ core four still ranks dead last, with an atrocious -24.6 Net Rating.
Basically, every single night, the Suns are beginning every game with a self-imposed handicap, regardless of who starts at center. The fact that they’re only one game below .500 is borderline miraculous, and it’s a testament to the strength of a bench that has routinely had to dig this team out of a hole.
How starters and bench players have performed for each team so far this season.
Starters playing better
Bench playing better https://t.co/TN3bY2o8z1 — Automatic (@automaticnba) November 16, 2026
Perhaps the most damning indictment of the Suns’ roster construction is the glaring difference in how much more the bench guys like Collin Gillespie, Luke Kennard, Jordan Goodwin and Ryan Dunn embody all the qualities that made last year’s team special.
Hell, even Los Angeles Lakers coach JJ Redick said the not-so-quiet part out loud:
“We’ve watched these guys all season, their second unit is their best unit right now,” Redick said, per AZ Family’s Julia Lopez. “That group with Gillespie and Kennard and Goodie and Dunn, that’s been their best unit this season. And I don’t even know what the numbers say, I’m just saying from watching, that unit plays like that unit that played last year, (like) their team played last year. They’re tough to guard. They move, they cut, they can all shoot, it’s a hard unit to guard.”
Redick may not know the numbers, but that’s what we’re here for. The Suns’ best five-man lineup this season in terms of total point differential is indeed a bench-heavy group, with Collin Gillespie, Luke Kennard, Jordan Goodwin, Miles Bridges and Oso Ighodaro being a +28 in 19 minutes together.
If that weren’t telling enough, the Suns’ top-four lineups in terms of total point differential all include Gillespie. Three of those four include Luke Kennard and Jordan Goodwin too. And Redick wasn’t wrong about Phoenix’s second unit playing more like last year’s team either.
There are three main areas that made last year’s Suns team so formidable: solid 3-point efficiency on high volume, elite defensive pressure that forced a ton of turnovers, and relentless crashing the boards for second chance opportunities. For reference, Phoenix ranked 12th in the NBA in 3-point percentage, fifth in 3-point attempts and makes, fourth in steals, third in opponent turnovers, fifth in points off turnovers, fourth in offensive rebounds and sixth in second chance points last season.
This season, the Suns have fallen off in most of these areas through the first 13 games. Although they rank second in points off turnovers, fifth in opponent turnovers and ninth in 3-point percentage, they’re only 16th in 3-point attempts, 14th in 3-point makes, 16th in steals, 19th in offensive rebounds and 24th in second chance points. And the bench is doing the heavy lifting in every single one of those categories.
Take the 3-point shooting. Being a top-10 team in 3-point percentage is a good thing! But the split between starters and bench players is pretty glaring:
- Suns starters: 34.0 3P% on 256 attempts
- Suns bench: 39.5 3P% on 233 attempts
Or how about the offensive boards?
- Suns starters: 64 offensive rebounds and 93 second chance points in 365 minutes
- Suns bench: 85 offensive rebounds and 92 second chance points in 259 minutes
Or what about when it comes to forcing turnovers and capitalizing on them?
- Suns starters: 54 steals, 125 opponent turnovers, 166 points off turnovers
- Suns bench: 50 steals, 90 opponent turnovers, 134 points off turnovers
Keep in mind, these totals come with the starters having logged 106 more minutes than the bench this season. On a per-minute basis, the bench unit has a higher assist rate, offensive rebounding rate, 3-point rate and steal rate, while also sporting a lower turnover rate.
In fairness, that can sometimes be easier to accomplish when you’re playing fewer minutes, but relative to the rest of the league, it’s obvious where the Suns’ starters and second unit stack up. Just check out how the Suns’ bench compares to the NBA’s other 29 benches…and where the starters stack up to every other team’s starters:
- Suns starters: 28th in 3PAs, 28th in 3PM, 20th in 3P%, 23rd in steals, 12th in opponent TOs, 8th in points off TOs, 30th in offensive rebounds, 28th in second chance points
- Suns bench: 5th in 3PAs, 2nd in 3PM, 4th in 3P%, 3rd in steals, 3rd in opponent TOs, 1st in points off TOs, 4th in offensive rebounds, 8th in second chance points
Those numbers are the epitome of one of the NBA’s best benches playing the way this team wants to play, compared to a starting lineup that just doesn’t make sense. Phoenix’s starters are being buoyed by the second unit on a near-nightly basis, and it’s telling that the Suns’ starters have a -92 total point differential (27th in the NBA among starters), while the bench unit is a +48 (second to only the Boston Celtics among reserves).
This is the primary reason the Suns’ recent success — and even their impressive win in Denver this week — feels unsustainable. As long as Jordan Ott (or the powers that be) refuses to change up that starting lineup, this team will continue to fight an uphill battle. It’s no longer “due diligence” when it’s clear to everyone involved that this group doesn’t work, and as long as the Suns remain stubborn on this front, they’ll be cutting off their nose to spite their face, largely because there’s still egg on it from their last few trades.
No one player deserves blame for how bad the Suns’ starters have performed; pretty much everyone except Devin Booker shares in this group’s failures. But it’s become abundantly clear that Jalen Green’s playmaking role (and all the propaganda that came with it) has failed, miscasting him and shoehorning him into things he’s not good at.
Now the Suns have a self-made Jalen Green problem on their hands, and outside of a trade, the only realistic solution feels like moving him to a bench role while bumping Collin Gillespie into the starting five.
He won’t be, but Dillon Brooks deserves to be on thin ice after his underwhelming start to the season, especially as the guy who’s meant to set the tone and safeguard the “culture” in Phoenix. If demoting Green doesn’t solve this team’s problems, moving Brooks or Miles Bridges to the bench shouldn’t be off the table as the next tweak to the starting lineup.
Granted, changing up the starting lineup will erode one of the Suns’ greatest strengths, diluting the bench unit with players who simply may not fit the way Phoenix wants to play. This roster is full of square pegs trying to fit into round holes, and removing Gillespie, Goodwin or Dunn from the second unit threatens to disrupt the chemistry of a group that’s clicking.
But depth is a much more useful tool during the regular season, because come playoff time, most teams ride their starters for 40 minutes a night. The Suns’ problem is that, so far this season, their best performers and their starters are largely not the same players. If the goal is to get this season back on track, reach the playoffs and maybe even win a series, that discrepancy matters.
Bench rotations shrivel up in the postseason, and while there’s still plenty of time to fix things and figure out who belongs in the playoff rotation, it’d be a lot more helpful if there were more overlap between the Suns’ starters and their most impactful players.
For more of Gerald Bourguet’s Suns work, check back with Sports360AZ on a weekly basis, subscribe to his Patreon articles and podcast at Suns After Dark, or follow him on Twitter.
The post A tale of two Suns: One of the NBA’s best benches is propping up one of its worst starting lineups first appeared on Sports360AZ.

