Site icon News Today

Judge Partially Dismisses Second Amended Wixen v. Meta Suit


Photo Credit: Jay Openiano

After 10 months of intense litigation, a federal judge has partially dismissed Wixen Music Publishing’s lawsuit against Meta – while allowing a substantial portion of the infringement and defamation action to proceed.  

Judge John Walter made that partial dismissal official in a concise order yesterday, after Meta moved to toss the second amended complaint in October. And as mentioned, the case itself, centering on a licensing agreement turned sour, dates back to 2026’s beginning.

That’s when Wixen formally accused the Instagram owner of making a lowball renewal offer that would have resulted in “drastically” reduced songwriter royalties. The proposal, the plaintiff claimed, aimed “to replace human-generated, royalty-bearing music with royalty-free AI-generated music.”

After the publisher rejected the terms but before the existing pact expired at 2025’s end, Meta allegedly began removing Wixen’s clients’ music (as well as former clients’ music) from its platforms.

And once the impacted professionals rather unsurprisingly inquired about the reasons behind the takedowns, Meta allegedly pinned the blame on Wixen, which purportedly lost clients as a result of the alleged defamation.

Meanwhile, Meta allegedly infringed the works in question by allowing their incorporation into “thousands” of users’ Reels following the licensing deal’s expiration.

September brought with it the case’s dismissal without prejudice – and the expectation that Wixen would submit a retooled action sooner rather than later. Right on cue, the publisher quickly filed an updated complaint alleging the infringement of 569 works (down from 681 previously).

Besides that change, essentially all the suit’s core elements remained the same. And the court’s newly issued dismissal has trimmed well over 200 of the allegedly infringed works that were registered prior to 1978 and, exclusive licensing agreements aside, aren’t directly owned by Wixen.

“Under the 1909 (Copyright) Act, copyright interests were traditionally treated as indivisible, such that an exclusive licensee ‘may not alone maintain an infringement action’ without joining the ‘copyright owner,’” Judge Walter wrote.

Because these owners aren’t aboard as plaintiffs, “Wixen lacks standing to assert its copyright infringement claims with respect to” the pre-1978 works at hand, per the judge.

Regarding the good news for Wixen, the court allowed the remainder of the claims, including the still-extensive infringement counts as well as the trade libel and defamation allegations, to proceed. Meta’s other dismissal arguments “are more appropriately resolved on a motion for summary judgment,” Judge Walter indicated.

Put differently, the multifaceted legal battle is far from over, and we’ll continue tracking the courtroom confrontation from here. Separately, Epidemic Sound v. Meta is playing out despite having kicked off in 2022, as is Eminem publisher Eight Mile Style’s more recently filed infringement suit.





–

Exit mobile version