Justin Langer has claimed the severe penalties handed down to Steve Smith, David Warner and Cameron Bancroft for their roles in the infamous Sandpapergate scandal changed cricket forever, in a subtle but impossible to miss way.
Australia’s ongoing Test series against South Africa is a long way removed from the combative, controversial series of the past.
Sledging has been at a minimum, skirmishes both on-field and off non-existent, and the mutual warmth between the two sides was summed up by Pat Cummins borrowing some tape from the Proteas camp to help mark his bowling run-up on match morning in Gqeberha.

Watch Australia’s Tour of South Africa Live & Exclusive on Fox Cricket, available on Kayo Sports.
It’s a far cry from the angst and the drama of the 2018 series, which became infamous for Sandpapergate but also featured regular run-ins between the two teams, including David Warner’s stoush with Quinton de Kock in a Durban stairwell and Kagiso Rabada’s on-field bump on Steve Smith, for which he was suspended but subsequently cleared.
For Langer, there is something even more obvious missing which was the most fearsome weapon in world cricket eight years ago: reverse swing.
Long one of cricket’s dark arts, teams for years used techniques that pushed the laws of cricket to their limits to generate the sharp, late swerve that earned the practice its name.
Early in the 2018 series, Mitchell Starc skittled the Proteas’ top order with a five-for in Durban in a single devastating spell of reverse-swing.
It was seeking a repeat in Cape Town that saw Bancroft discovered as having brought a sheet of sandpaper onto the field to roughen up one side of the ball to aid the practice.
Speaking on Amazon Prime’s In the Middle with Watto podcast, Langer, who took over as Australian men’s coach following Darren Lehmann’s resignation in the aftermath of Sandpapergate, claimed its disappearance over the last eight years is proof it wasn’t only the Australians creating reverse swing by illegal means.
“In my opinion, Steve Smith, David Warner (and) Cameron Bancroft not only took the fall for the Australian cricket team, they also took it for cricketers all around the world,” Langer said.
“The ball has not reverse swung anywhere in the world since that day, including both teams (Australia and South Africa) in the first two Test matches.
“The ball hasn’t reverse swung. Simple.”
While reverse swing has been seen on occasions in Test cricket since 2018, its prevalence, as well as its status as a major talking point, has been substantially reduced.
Langer pointed to a comment made by former England great Andrew Flintoff in the aftermath of Sandpapergate as having proved eerily prescient.
Flintoff, whose England stunned Australia 2-1 in the 2005 Ashes in part due to a practice of using mint-flavoured saliva to shine the ball and get it to hoop, urged other nations against “chucking stones”.
“The Prime Minister’s banging his chest, I watched a really smug documentary that the South Africans made … I felt like vomiting the whole time I was watching it,” Langer said.
“I went to England when Steve Smith and David Warner came back for the World Cup – the way they were treated was disgusting.
“Literally as bad adult human behaviour as I’ve ever seen. It made me sick.
“While everyone’s pouring everything on Australia, Andrew Flintoff said three words: “Those in glass houses”.
“Ball has not reverse swung since. Go figure.”
However, Langer said he remains sympathetic for Bancroft’s plight, who unlike Smith and Warner never recovered on an international level from his nine-month suspension.
The then-25-year-old has played just two Tests since, during the 2019 Ashes, having finished the 2018 South African tour as Australia’s leading run-scorer.
Langer, who played a pivotal role alongside captain Tim Paine in changing Australia’s culture from 2018 onwards, said it was “a horrible time in Australian cricket”.
“The boys were penalised very harshly and not just in missing out, the way they were treated,” he said.
“It’ll be a stain, it’ll be a scar.
“I feel very sorry for Cameron Bancroft. It was a very tough time to take over and to see it happen.”
Reverse swing has by and large been replaced by the “wobble seam”, a now commonplace practice where bowlers hold the seam at an angle, rather than perfectly upright, in order to generate uneven movement.
It’s a technique Scott Boland has used to devastating effect throughout his late-career Test breakthrough, including during his four-wicket haul in the Proteas’ ongoing first innings in Gqeberha.
A worldwide trend in which pitches have grown steadily bowler-friendly, particularly towards fast bowlers, has also lessened the need for reverse-swing as a wicket-taking method.