A coalition of major music industry organizations submitted amicus briefs in U.S. District Court in favor of the District of Columbia’s RESALE Act.
Last week, a coalition of ten organizations representing hundreds of thousands of musicians, songwriters, performers, artists, managers, and fans submitted amicus briefs in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia’s RESALE Act. The law—unanimously passed by the D.C. Council earlier this year—caps ticket resale prices and fees, takes on bots and speculative listings, and requires price transparency.
However, it is under attack in two separate lawsuits: Ticket Policy Forum, Inc. v. District of Columbia, brought by a group that includes resale exchanges SeatGeek, Vivid Seats, Gametime, and TickPick; and National Association of Ticketing Professionals v. District of Columbia, brought by ticket brokers.
The amici include the American Federation of Musicians, Artist Rights Alliance, Fan Alliance, Future of Music Coalition, Music Artists Coalition, Music Managers Forum-US, National Independent Talent Organization (NITO), Recording Academy, SAG-AFTRA, and the Songwriters of North America.
“The RESALE Act is the secondary market’s worst nightmare. It puts the benefits of fair ticketing right in front of the people who write federal legislation. Members of Congress, their staff, and federal employees will see firsthand what a ticket market free of price gouging and scalpers looks like,” said Nathaniel Marro, Executive Director of NITO. “This lawsuit is a last-ditch effort to stop progress for fans and artists across the country before common sense ticket reforms hit the halls of Congress.”
“The D.C. Council saw predatory resellers taking advantage of fans and had the courage to do something about it with the RESALE Act,” said Ron Gubitz, Executive Director at the Music Artists Coalition. “Now this multibillion-dollar industry is trying to bully the citizens of the District with cynical legal arguments, because their business models depend on gouging fans and skimming off artists. MAC is proud to stand with artists and fans in defense of common sense policy in the District.”
In their briefs, the coalition argues that the resale market currently serves brokers, not fans. Brokers buy tickets in bulk, often with bots, and sell speculative tickets they do not have, creating false scarcity and driving up prices. The law’s price caps are designed to protect fans, artists, and workers. They remove the profit incentive behind bots and speculation, stop brokers from capturing discounts intended for fans, and keep more of each ticket dollar with artists and crew.
Further, they argue that uncapped resale does not constrain Ticketmaster. The plaintiffs claim that the secondary ticketing market checks Ticketmaster, but uncapped resale allows the ticketing giant to extract more, charging multiple rounds of fees and markups, from the same fans. Finally, they argue that capped resale works at scale; Maine and Vermont already cap resale, and one exchange resold more than 4,000 tickets in Western Australia to sold-out Coldplay shows, under a cap nearly identical to the District’s.
“The RESALE Act is a big step toward a fair and transparent ticketing economy, but it is not a novel regulation,” said Katherine Van Dyck of KVD Strategies, who prepared and filed the briefs. “Laws regulating and capping ticket resale and speculation have existed for over a century, and judges, including the Supreme Court in 1965, have rejected nearly every constitutional challenge they have faced.”
Meanwhile, the plaintiffs bring commerce clause, due process, and equal protection challenges to the RESALE Act. A hearing on their motions for a preliminary injunction, which asks the court to block the law’s implementation and enforcement, is set for Thursday, November 19, at 10 AM.

