It was another mixed bag for the Australians in the second Test against South Africa.

There was some brilliance from Victorian Scott Boland with both bat and ball, leaving you wondering whether he is one of the unluckiest cricketers in Australian history.

Watch Australia’s Tour of South Africa Live & Exclusive on Fox Cricket, available on Kayo Sports | Get Kayo now

But the same batting concerns emerged once again, with Nic Maddinson, Marnus Labuschagne and Beau Webster all producing worrying performances for the Aussies.

So who stood up, and who struggled?

We rate all 11 Australians from the second Test against South Africa below.

WRAP: Cult hero’s 3-hour vigil, Head ton not enough as Aussies sink to crushing Test defeat

TALKING PTS: Why Marnus irks Aussie greats so much; ‘honest’ reveal in selection ‘madness’

NIC MADDINSON – 1

0 & 8: 0/24

Gqeberha was a nightmare for Australia’s latest opener.

Kagiso Rabada started Maddinson’s Test career of in brutal fashion a decade ago by knocking him over with a cracking yorker under lights in Adelaide.

Rabada may have ended it at St George’s Park as nicked the left-hander off cheaply in both innings.

Maddinson only had to survive one over from Rabada on the third evening before bad light forced the South Africans to bowl their spinner, but he perished for a fourth ball duck – poking outside off stump to be caught at third slip.

His second innings less than a day later was not much better, and prodding at a ball he could have let go and feathering a catch into the glove of Ryan Rickelton.

After five Tests in his career, Maddinson has scored 83 runs at 10.37. It is grim reading for the 34-year-old, who a shock call-up for this tour have a battle with testicular cancer kept him out of last summer’s Sheffield Shield.

Khawaja analyses Maddinson Test 2 duck | 01:26

TRAVIS HEAD – 8

14 & 121

His former teammates Moises Henriques and Usman Khawaja shared their belief on Kayo Sports during the second Test that Head belongs at No.5, but his second innings vigil at least ensured Australia does not have two opener problems heading to Cape Town.

A clever review from the South Africans sent him on his way lbw to Marco Jansen in the first innings – Jansen convinced his captain Temba Bavuma that Head had smashed his pad and not the ball after a half-hearted appeal.

Later on day four, Australian fans who stayed up to watch their team follow-on for only the third time this century saw the Travis Head that the nation has fallen in love with.

The left-hander was not as free-flowing as he was during the Ashes last summer, but showed he is made of tough stuff.

The South Africans have bowled far tighter too him than England did, and he fought and scrapped his way to a second overseas century – the first against opposition in their own backyard – and the 13th of his Test career.

It was Head’s fourth century in nine Tests since moving to the top of the order, and was vital in ensuring that the debacle of the first innings was not repeated.

‘NOT ABOUT THE HUNDRED’: Head caps off 12-month rampage with latest ton to enter new frontier

Australia's Travis Head celebrates his hundred on day five of the second cricket test match between South Africa and Australia, in Gqeberha, South Africa, Thursday, Oct. 22, 2026. (AP Photo/Themba Hadebe)
Australia’s Travis Head celebrates his hundred on day five of the second cricket test match between South Africa and Australia, in Gqeberha, South Africa, Thursday, Oct. 22, 2026. (AP Photo/Themba Hadebe)Source: AP

MARNUS LABUSCHAGNE – 3

14 & 39; 1/8

The narrative of Australia’s No.3 fighting for his career rolls on.

Labuschagne fell in all too familar fashion in the first innings, edging Anrich Nortje into the slip cordon, while his second innings dismissal sparked outrage across the nation.

The Queenslander had been given a reprieve three runs earlier when ball tracking overturned an lbw decision as it shows Simon Harmer’s delivery was spinning too much to miss leg stump by a coat of paint.

He failed to make the most of the stroke of good fortune, however.

With Harmer bowling tight, Labuschagne decided to go on the attack.

He ran at the off spinner, tried to smack him over the long on fence in a strong wind and was well caught by Marco Jansen running back with the flight.

Similar brain explosions have cost players their international careers and after three scores in the 30s in four innings on this tour, the 32-year-old is once again in the gun.

Mcdonald gives blunt Marnus assessment | 09:20

STEVE SMITH – 3

28 & 3

The champion batter surpassed 11,000 Test runs – just the third Australian behind Ricky Ponting and Allan Border to reach that milestone – as he top-scored with wickets falling around him in the first innings.

Smith is well-known for being theatrical at the crease, but this was different as he appeared uncomfortable, not in his own bubble.

He had treatment besides the pitch for a neck issue after throwing the kitchen sink at a back foot drive off Kagiso Rabada.

It eventually meant he did not bat at his customary No.4 spot in the second innings, and he looked uncomfortable when he did come to the crease on day five.

Smith then fell in very unusual fashion, miscuing a pull shot off Rabada early in his innings and against the second new ball.

GQEBERHA, SOUTH AFRICA – OCTOBER 21: Steve Smith of Australia celebrates 11000 career test runs during day 4 of the 2nd Dafabet Test match between South Africa and Australia at St Georges Park on October 21, 2026 in Gqeberha, South Africa. (Photo by Richard Huggard – Gallo Images/Getty Images)Source: Getty Images

MATT RENSHAW – 2

12 & 11; 0/33

Australia’s hero of Durban had a far tougher time of things in Gqerberha.

A tough two days for the Queenslander began with Marco Jansen slamming him for a massive six that almost smashed a commentary box window.

After having a golden arm at Kingsmead, Renshaw’s tweakers proved ineffective in the absence of Nathan Lyon on day three.

But the 30-year-old is in the side to score runs and attempted to dig in on each occasion when like Labuschagne and Webster, he was dismissed twice in the same day.

Jansen got the better of him again in the first innings, with his extra bounce finding the shoulder of Renshaw’s bat and he was caught at gully as a result.

In the second dig, when he was promoted to No.4 due to Steve Smith’s neck issue, Rabada got him around the wicket with one he would not want to watch him.

Renshaw shouldered arms to a ball that nipped back in, and it crashed into his off stumps via a deflection off his pad. He was effectively out bowled and lbw in the same ball.

The question for Renshaw now is whether he will return to opening in Cape Town despite making 190 and 82 at No.5 in the first Test.

Australia’s Matt Renshaw is bowled by South Africa’s Kagiso Rabada on day four of the second Test match between South Africa and Australia at St Georges Park in Gqeberha on October 21, 2026. Australia were made to follow on after being dismissed for just 99 in reply to South Africa’s first innings total of 425 for nine declared, a deficit of 326 runs, on day four at Gqeberha. (Photo by Marco Longari / AFP)Source: AFP

ALEX CAREY – 5

0 & 37*; four catches

The Australian wicketkeeper came into the second Test looking to find some form with the bat, but it was another mixed bag for Alex Carey.

His first innings couldn’t have gone much worse, dismissed for a duck by Marco Jansen after facing just two deliveries.

But he responded in the second innings, digging deep to score 37 runs from 69 balls, although his efforts weren’t enough to get the Aussies over the line.

Behind the stumps, Carey was solid, taking four catches in the first innings, with two coming off Scott Boland and another two off Mitchell Starc.

After scores of 14 and 24 in the opening Test, there were some encouraging signs with the bat, but Carey will be hoping for a more complete performance heading into the third and final Test.

South Africa’s Ryan Rickelton (R) celebrates as Australia’s Alex Carey (L) walks back to the pavilion after his dismissal on day four of the second Test match between South Africa and Australia at St Georges Park in Gqeberha on October 21, 2026. (Photo by Marco Longari / AFP)Source: AFP

BEAU WEBSTER – 2

13 & 8; 0/43

The towering Tasmanian was dropped for the Ashes at the start of last summer, but now his Test future is seriously under scrutiny.

He began the Test by sending down 19 handy overs of medium pace to help out captain Pat Cummins more than usual due to Josh Hazlewood being ill, but Webster looked unthreatening on a placid pitch with an older ball despite bowling economically.

With the bat was the major concern, however.

Nicked off pushing at a back of length delivery from Jansen, who rubbed salt in the wounds by giving a Webster a send off as he clinched a five-wicket haul, in the first innings.

Then was promoted ahead of wicketkeeper Alex Carey to No.5 in Steve Smith’s absence as Australia followed-on.

Dug in for 33 balls with Travis Head, but was eventually trapped lbw by the spin of Simon Harmer.

Webster went back in front of all three stumps and it was so dead that he did not even bother contemplating a review.

Since the start of the Bangladesh series, Webster’s scores read: 12, 5, 0, 4, 39*, 13 and 8.

The 39 not out came chasing quick runs in the second innings in Durban, but such a lean patch has his place in the side in question with Cameron Green on the comeback trail.

READ MORE

England star goes NUCLEAR with historic 202 as records tumble in stunning ODI knock

Tassie hero’s six-wicket epic sinks Vics; WA batters survive late scare despite Konstas ton – Wrap

Australia’s Beau Webster walks back to the pavilion after his dismissal on day four of the second Test match between South Africa and Australia at St Georges Park in Gqeberha on October 21, 2026. (Photo by Marco Longari / AFP)Source: AFP

PAT CUMMINS – 3

0/96; 7 & 4

Cummins endured perhaps his worst Test as Australian captain.

Went wicketless and registered his second worst figures in a Test innings as his counterpart Temba Bavuma won an engrossing battle between the rivals skippers.

Cummins was unlucky that Marnus Labuschagne put down a chance at leg slip off Ryan Rickelton on the second evening that could have at least got him in the wicket column.

Then after his heroics with the bat in Durban, lived up the latter half of his nickname 7/11. Holing out in the deep to be the final Australian to fall as the team was rolled for 99 in the first innings, and being knocked over by a beauty from Wiaan Mulder on the final day.

Australia’s captain Pat Cummins reacts after bowling on day two of the second cricket test match between South Africa and Australia, in Gqeberha, South Africa, Monday, Oct. 19, 2026. (AP Photo/Themba Hadebe)Source: AP

MITCHELL STARC – 4

3/89; 1 & 11

The champion left-armer picked up his 450th Test wicket, becoming just the fourth Australian to reach that milestone, as he battled admirably.

Was below his best though despite picking up three wickets – including eventually removing Temba Bavuma on 179 after more than nine hours at the crease.

Also struggled to make an impact with the bat, but has plenty of credits in the bank despite being knocked over by Kagiso Rabada late on day five.

Starc gets Mulder for his 450th wicket | 01:53

SCOTT BOLAND – 8

5/81; 2 & 40

Returned to the baggy green with a bang, knocking over the South African top three and four of the top six during the limited play across the first two days.

Boland had the ball talking on a fresh surface to deeply trouble the Proteas top order and then toiled admirably on day three when the ball got soft and the pitch flattened out.

Struck again with the second new ball to remove Marco Jansen 15 runs shy of a maiden Test ton, and to clinch his third five-wicket haul.

Also, did his job as nightwatchman superbly.

He survived until stumps on each occasion, but after being dismissed on the first ball he faced on day four, Boland made amends on the final day.

He dug in, posted his highest Test score, played the longest innings of his career to give Australia hope of survival and showed some of his teammates higher up the order how to defend.

Now, the Australian selectors must ponder how to keep him in the team for Cape Town if they want to bring back Nathan Lyon.

“Got a couple of years left in me!” | 02:43

JOSH HAZLEWOOD – 3

0/43; 2 & 0

After starring with six wickets in the second innings in Durban, Hazlewood was struck down with illness in Gqeberha and was a shell of himself.

Stayed at the hotel to rest and recover as Australia fielded for 30.4 overs in day two. He then had to wait that same amount of time in the outfield on day three before he could return to the bowling crease.

Once he did after the lunch break, his pace was down and Hazlewood lacked any venom.

The bout of sickness took its toll, unfortunately.



–