Jermaine Dupri. Photo Credit: Eva Rinaldi
One month after dropping his multimillion-dollar Sony Music infringement lawsuit, Jermaine Dupri is staring down a copyright complaint for allegedly lifting from a decades-old work to create 2023’s “Pick It Up.”
The members of hip-hop duo Home Team, brothers Patrick Watler and Van J. Watler, just recently submitted the concise action to a Florida federal court. As described in the suit, the filing parties dropped “Pick It Up” about 35 years back.
Fast forward to 2023, when Dupri and fellow defendant Jacquees released the above-noted effort of the same name. Per the plaintiffs, the newer “Pick It Up” incorporated “the protectable elements of the” older title, referring specifically to “protectable lyrics and melody/harmony,” without authorization.
The legal text is light on concrete details here – including about the precise nature of the infringement, when and how the defendants (also including Mass Appeal) might have accessed the Home Team song at hand, and more.
(Nevertheless, the same document emphasizes that the plaintiffs may well tack on defendants and/or “move to amend these counts should additional counts and/or claims” surface moving forward.)
But the alleged overlap can seemingly be traced to the songs’ choruses, both featuring the titular “pick it up” line. And while it probably goes without saying at this point, the plaintiffs are adamant that Dupri and Jacquees “never sought” their approval to use the older “Pick It Up” and allegedly “failed to compensate” them “in anyway whatsoever.”
All told, Home Team is seeking damages for the alleged infringement or, alternatively, for the defendants’ alleged unjust enrichment – besides credits on Dupri’s “Pick It Up.”
With that, we’ve another potentially involved copyright showdown to track. Of course, at this early stage of the game, we don’t know how the dispute will play out. But thanks to a mountain of similar courtroom confrontations and adjacent legal-fees pushes, we do know that the cases are decidedly expensive – which is good news for attorneys (and musicologists) but not the litigants.
Earlier in September, for instance, Lady Gaga and Universal Music formally demanded over $230,000 in attorneys’ fees from surf brand Lost International as part of an ugly trademark clash. However, said demand is seemingly on the backburner at present, as Lost is now spearheading a Ninth Circuit appeal following the case’s dismissal with prejudice.
Meanwhile, Bad Bunny reportedly incurred an eye-watering bill when fending off an “Enséñame Bailar” copyright suit. And logic suggests that the separate “Frankenstein” reggaeton action, which is chugging along despite a summary judgment setback for the plaintiffs, isn’t coming cheap for the Debí Tirar Más Fotos act or the many other defendants.

Leave a Reply