Suno Italy investigation

Rome, Italy. Photo Credit: Jakub Sitar

When it rains, it pours and, in Suno’s case, keeps on pouring: Besides facing a number of stateside lawsuits as well as international copyright claims, the AI music generator is now grappling with a formal investigation in Italy over its allegedly “unfair terms.”

The Italian Competition Authority (ICA) disclosed the probe in a brief release today, highlighting what it sees as “a significant imbalance of consumer rights and obligations” in the AI music platform’s terms of service.

Behind this alleged imbalance, the competition watchdog emphasized Suno’s purportedly “broad discretion to make unilateral changes to the contract, the service and the subscription prices, without having to provide any justification” – on top of its alleged ability to boot users and content as it sees fit.

Admittedly, none of that seems too far out of the ordinary; digital platforms’ axing accounts, removing certain media, and upping prices isn’t exactly unprecedented. The ICA also voiced concerns about the terms’ allegedly requiring “users to consent to additional terms, which they have no direct access to before entering into the contract.”

Meanwhile, the agency further noted Suno’s arbitration provision and took aim at the terms for allegedly limiting the company’s liability through “very broad and generic” language.

Most interestingly, the ICA expressed the belief that Suno’s “contractual provisions on copyright deserve particular attention.”

“The scope of the license imposed on consumers as a condition for using the platform services seems to be insufficiently defined, as it is framed in generic and all-encompassing terms, and imposes the waiver of moral rights,” the entity wrote.

Shifting to the terms themselves, “you irrevocably waive any and all so-called ‘moral rights’ or ‘droit moral’ that may exist in or in connection with the Content or your Voice Model,” some of the relevant text reads.

Plus, “this license authorizes us to make your Content (including Output that incorporates your Voice Model, but, for clarity, not your Voice Model itself) available to and sublicense such Content to other users of the Service as necessary.”

Regarding the investigation’s next steps, a public consultation is scheduled to begin during “the next few weeks,” with interested parties weighing in via “a dedicated section of” the Italian Competition Authority website.

And as mentioned, the inquiry marks the latest in a line of legal and regulatory headaches for Suno, which is fending off multiple suits pertaining to a reported data breach, copyright claims from the non-Warner majors, and several artist-led infringement actions.





–