Suno Universal Music lawsuit

The John Joseph Moakley Courthouse. Photo Credit: 4300streetcar

The non-Warner majors are firing back against Suno’s push to stay the second of their high-stakes legal battles. Per Universal Music and Sony Music, delaying the case “would not merely postpone building the record, it would degrade it.”

The litigating majors took aim at the AI music platform’s request across nearly 20 detail-oriented pages; late October had seen Suno ask the court to put the second case on ice while the first of the actions played out.

With the Suno infringement suits (and related subpoenas) flying, a recap could prove useful here. The plaintiff majors – Warner Music, most know, has settled with and licensed the defendant – originally moved to supersize their claims with another 60,000 or so allegedly infringed works.

The presiding judge denied the request, indicating that approving it would “delay the resolution of this case for an indefinite period of time,” but left the door open for a follow-up complaint.

Right on cue, the filing parties charged ahead with a separate-but-similar action, zeroing in on Suno v6 (meaning the trio of models created in partnership with Warner Music and others) therein.

Returning to Suno’s motion, the BMG-partnered company urged the court to halt the newer dispute pending an answer to the all-important fair use question in UMG v. Suno I.

“If the Court finds that Suno’s conduct was fair use or that YouTube’s technological measures do not support a claim under Section 1201(a), UMG I could foreclose Plaintiffs’ theories of liability in UMG II,” Suno wrote.

“Rather than proceed with discovery in UMG II subject to this uncertainty, including two very different views on how the fair use factors should apply to Plaintiffs’ claims, the Court should stay UMG II pending resolution of UMG I to avoid the significant burdens and inefficiencies of duplicative and potentially unnecessary litigation,” the defendant continued.

Though Universal Music and Sony Music “agree with Suno that the Court’s resolution of the fair use question” in UMG v. Suno I “will, at the very least, be instructive in this case,” they are, as mentioned, opposed to a complete pause in the second suit.

Consequently, they’re on board with temporarily shelving “work-specific discovery into the ownership of the more than 60,000 sound recordings asserted here,” but not with “Suno’s request that this action be frozen in its entirety, for a period that could realistically extend into 2028, while Suno continues to train, release, license, and monetize models that require independent scrutiny.”

“By the time discovery into v6 could begin under Suno’s proposal, the engineers who built the models may have moved on, their recollections will have faded and the training pipelines they used may have changed significantly or been superseded,” the plaintiff majors penned.

What, then, is the solution? According to Universal Music and Sony Music, “a partial stay” – including a pause on the above-noted work-specific side – is the way to go. And making “all discovery taken in Suno I…usable in this action” would purportedly eliminate “the duplication Suno claims to fear.”

As for the scope of the floated “tailored discovery,” Suno’s v6 products and “ongoing model training” practices would be on the table. So would the business’s financial positioning and “commercial footprint,” referring to fresh features as well as new raises “and the presentations made to investors in connection with them.”

Closing with a quick look at where UMG v. Suno I’s marathon discovery process stands, it was only last week that the litigants’ counsel attempted to hash out a number of disagreements. Additionally, third-party subpoena clashes, involving Nvidia, the Mechanical Licensing Collective, several Suno investors, Apple, and DistroKid, are still unfolding.





–