Rugby league in England is at a crossroads, according to one of its former greats, as the NRL bids to take control of the struggling Super League.
Watch Australia’s Tour of South Africa Live & Exclusive on Fox Cricket, available on Kayo Sports | New to Kayo? Join now and get your first month for just $1.
There was a time when the English ruled the rugby league world, and many young Australians probably don’t realise it was the Kangaroos who went 30 years without winning an Ashes series at one point.
WHAT’S GAMBLING REALLY COSTING YOU? Set a deposit limit. For Free and confidential support call 1800 858 858 or visit gamblinghelponline.org.au.
But those glory days occurred a long time ago, and the last time the English won an Ashes series was in 1970.
They backed up that success in 1972 with their third World Cup win.
Since then, there has been a gradual decline, which has accelerated in the past decade to the point where tiny Pacific Island nations are dominating the country that invented the game.
Is the NRL takeover the only thing that can save the game in England?
Foxsports.com.au takes a look at the evolving situation as ARLC boss Peter V’landys clashes with English Super League owners, who have also come into question over their motives.
NRL TRIES TO SAVE SUPER LEAGUE
V’landys, the powerful NRL boss, has offered to pay $57 million as a financial rescue package for the cash-strapped English Super League.
In return, it would receive a 50 per cent stake in the league and ensure the immediate promotion of the London Broncos to the top division.
He gave the Super League a deadline of October 15 to agree to the deal, which rubbed some owners up the wrong way, and to date there has been no agreement.
Olakau’atu stars in Tonga vs England | 02:06
ULTIMATE GUIDE: Everything you need to know ahead of the 2026 Rugby League World Cup
FIXTURES: Full 2026 Rugby League World Cup schedule… and how it works
In response, V’landys warned that the game in England was heading for a “train crash” if it didn’t grow its revenue.
He wants the London Broncos in the Super League due to the 750,000 Aussies he claims are living in the city, which he said had a “ready-made audience”.
“All our business models and our analysis require London Broncos to be part of it. We take a bigger risk if they’re not in the Super League,” he told CODE Sports last week.
Despite the financial rescue package, which is desperately needed, the English clubs could not come to an agreement last week and declined the NRL offer.
Leigh Leopards owner Derek Beaumont then took to social media to have a shot at V’landys.
“Giving a deadline on something you want that the other side cannot commit to is a gun-to-the-head approach akin to a ransom,” Beaumont posted on X.
“I will not vote to add London to SL (Super League) without due process and most certainly not because someone insists upon it.
“Let’s pause here and remember that this person (V’landys), as chairman of who would control SL under the deal, has in a short space of time significantly changed the goalposts from what he said to what then became the offer.”
English rugby league great James Roby told Foxsports.com.au from England this week that the long-term future of the English game was at stake in the coming weeks and months.
“We’re at a crossroads really for the game and we need a positive outcome from this,” Roby said.
“I think for too long we’ve almost plateaued as a sport over here. We’ve just stayed the same for a long time, really, so it’s time for a change.
“There’s just a bit of uncertainty in the water at the minute in the English game.”
Roby and others in the north of England are still stunned at the NRL’s $5.3 billion broadcast rights deal, which was announced in July.
While he knows the English game will never get close to that, their last deal was for just $123 million over three seasons. Roby said the game needed a quick financial turnaround.
“The NRL’s broadcast deal is astronomical, but ours has actually decreased over the last couple of years,” he said.
“Broadcast deals are your biggest revenue earner in the sport, so it’s very challenging times at the minute.
“I’m very interested to see what happens and what the outcome could be.”
Super League managing director Rhodri Jones has met with NRL officials in the past week in the hope of sorting out a deal.
Mitch Moses to miss WC with shin injury | 00:24
WILL THERE BE A BREAKAWAY COMP?
With negotiations at this stage breaking down between the NRL and Super League, there have even been suggestions of a breakaway competition in England.
England great James Graham and former NRL coach Shane Flanagan agreed that serious changes needed to be made to save the game in the northern hemisphere.
Graham, speaking on The Bye Round podcast, has now even classified rugby league in England as a “niche” sport.
“I’m not too sure where this (NRL-Super League partnership) goes from here,” he said.
“Unfortunately, rugby league in England, I say this with respect, is becoming a niche sport. A lot of people in the country wouldn’t know a World Cup is being played now by a rugby code.
“A lot of people would have no real idea of how to watch or consume that product. You go on the main pages of the main sports news, and it’s a blip.”
Flanagan touted the idea of some clubs forming a rebel competition, and Graham said it would be naive to think those conversations aren’t happening.
“You’d have to be considering it,” he said.
Flanagan believes the likes of Wigan, St Helens, Warrington and Leeds must be sick of the seemingly terminal decline the game is in.
Roby, meanwhile, told foxsports.com.au that he’s heard the rumours about a possible rebel competition.
He said the fact the clubs are so divided in England is the bigger issue.
The self-interest in the game is playing a big role in halting its growth.
“An issue that we’ve had for many, many years over here is the clubs don’t seem to agree on a lot of stuff. There’s always a divide,” he said.
“We just need to get on the same page somehow and get everybody on a level playing field and get everybody ultimately thinking in the best interests of the game as a whole.
“I understand that people have got to make decisions for their own best interests at times, but it just feels to me that we need to make decisions in the best interests of the game.
“That’s potentially the crossroads that we’re at with the NRL.”
Young Chiefs signing stars for PNG Kumul | 00:54
Get all the latest NRL news, highlights and analysis delivered straight to your inbox with Fox Sports Sportmail. Sign up now!!!
There’s clearly issues holding the game back at an administrative level.
It’s not an issue the NRL has because V’landys has the power to just go an get things done as the clubs trust him to take the game in the right direction both on and off the field.
V’landys brought riches to racing in NSW while in charge there and the same is happening with rugby league in Australia.
He wants to do it in England — if they let him.
THE STRATEGY TO RULE THE WORLD AGAIN
If England, who are currently battling for survival in the World Cup, are to become a dominant force on the international stage again, it needs to start with its domestic footy.
The equation is simple: have a strong Super League and you’ll have a strong national team.
“We need the product and the brand to improve,” Roby said.
It all starts with the broadcast deal, which the Super League is closing in on following talks with DAZN.
It’s expected that a 12-month agreement with DAZN will see the broadcaster show four Super League games per round in 2027.
“We look at the NRL, for example, and your broadcast deal is absolutely through the roof. The players are brands themselves,” Roby said.
“The challenge with us in England is that we have never been the number one sport.
“We’re always playing second fiddle to football, which is obviously played everywhere, and we are still very much north-west-based.
“I think there’s obviously change on the horizon and hopefully it will be good for the game and hopefully it brings more revenue in. We need more revenue in the game, and we need to innovate and take steps forward.”
There have been bright spots of late, including English Super League champions defeating NRL powerhouses Penrith and Brisbane in the past three World Club Challenges.
Roby led St Helens to a famous win over the sensational Penrith side in Australia in 2023 in wet conditions at Penrith Park.
“Our English boys, on the day, can turn it on and they are capable of beating anybody,” he said.
“I think it’s fair to say that the NRL is obviously a stronger competition across the board.
“The biggest difference is the consistency of the intensity of your games. We don’t have that over here at the minute.”
Goosebumps from Fijian hymn | 01:33
Roby pointed to Wakefield Trinity’s fairy-tale rise to win the Super League this year as further evidence the competition is strengthening.
It was Wakefield’s first premiership in the top tier since 1968.
“It’s getting better by the way. You look at Wakefield, I wouldn’t have expected them to be thereabouts come the end of the season, so fair play to them,” Roby said.
“The competition is slowly getting stronger, but if we’re going into a 14 or 15-team competition next year, we need at least 10 of those teams to go into it with a chance of winning.
“We just need to get that consistent high standard on a weekly basis. So you build up that exposure to the intensity and obviously then, when you get to those bigger international games, everybody’s accustomed to it.”
Another issue holding back the English game is the attitude of its fans.
One of the reasons why the NRL secured a huge broadcast deal this year was that Australian rugby league fans tend to watch most of the games on TV.
Canterbury Bulldogs supporters, for example, will watch their team play on a Thursday night and still take in the other games where possible over the weekend.
It keeps the TV ratings high across the board, which leads to the large broadcast deal and rivers of gold that now flow through the sport.
Kiwis survive almighty Fiji scare | 00:48
But in England, most fans do the opposite.
They’ll watch their team play and then change the channel for the rest of the weekend and pay no attention to neutral games.
It makes it impossible to secure a lucrative broadcast deal, so that’s something that needs to be addressed.
“I think a culture change could be to get people to support their county, whether that’s Lancashire or Yorkshire,” Roby said.
ENGLAND’S INTERNATIONAL WOES
England’s loss to Tonga in the opening game of the current World Cup being played in Australia has likely ended their chances of making the knockout stage.
Tell English fans that 10 years ago and they would’ve laughed at the prospect of Tonga beating England by 18 points in a World Cup game.
But again, that loss goes back to the Super League competition.
The Tongan players are all NRL stars, while only a handful of the English are competing in the stronger Australian competition.
Fiji make statement against Cook Islands | 02:32
Roby, who played for England and Great Britain 39 times and for St Helens on 551 occasions, admitted the rise of Pacific Island nations has been a good thing for rugby league.
But he fears England is being left behind.
“In the past Australia and New Zealand have always been the top two nations and we’ve almost been hanging around that area, being third and trying to catch up,” he said.
“I think it’s really interesting over the last five years to see the rise of Samoa and Tonga in particular.
“It’s been absolutely fantastic for the international game. Those nations are now competing at the highest level, which is great for the international game, but from an English perspective, it means we can’t take our position for granted.”
In a way, Jason Taumalolo’s 2017 decision to defect from New Zealand, where he was born, to play for Tonga due to his family heritage has ended England’s chances of winning the World Cup.
Taumalolo’s decision influenced many other players with Pacific Island heritage, and dozens have now followed him in playing for Tonga and Samoa.
The latter even made the World Cup final in 2021 after knocking England out in the semis at the Emirates Stadium in London.
“We’re not trying to catch up to Australia and New Zealand. We’re obviously now battling with Samoa and Tonga,” Roby said.
With the way this year’s World Cup group stage works, the loser of the England v Tonga match was likely not to qualify for the semis.
Roby knows England must not only beat France this week but also put a big score on them.
Samoa and Tonga do play each other, so one will lose, but if it’s Tonga and they finish on the same points as England, they will go through on a countback.
Samoa beat France 78-4 in their opening match while England lost by 18, so that for-and-against difference is huge.
If England can rack up a huge total against France at Perth Stadium on Saturday night, it will put pressure on Samoa to beat Tonga to assure their progress to the semis.
“I think people are very quick to write England off because it is quite a harsh format if you lose that first game like we have,” Roby said.
“Don’t get me wrong, Australia and New Zealand have set the benchmark in terms of consistency over the years, but there’s no reason why we can’t beat them.”
WILL ENGLAND EVER WIN THE WORLD CUP?
Great Britain won World Cups in 1954, 1960 and 1972.
Now playing as England, the Poms have been runners-up in 1975, 1995 and 2017.
They only lost the 2017 final 6-0 to Australia, but they seem a mile off getting that close to being crowned world champions these days.
Roby made 56 tackles for England that night and, when asked if he’ll ever see his nation hold aloft the Paul Barrière Trophy, he was optimistic.
“Hopefully, yeah,” Roby said.
“There’s no reason why not. If you have the mindset where England can’t win a World Cup, then what’s the point?
“We’ve always got to be patriotic and have belief in ourselves as a squad and a nation.”
Dolphins centre Herbie Farnworth is probably England’s best player at the World Cup, but he was off his game against Tonga.
The English really need to develop halves if they’re ever going to have a real chance of winning the trophy back.
Then there are the mental scars of not having success for decades, which no doubt are causing confidence issues.
“There are green shoots, there are positive things happening. We’ve got a lot of English players who are playing in the NRL currently who are doing a great job,” Roby said.
“I think the key for us is to get over that initial hurdle of winning on the biggest stage and winning on the international stage, and a World Cup obviously doesn’t get any bigger than that. It’s a challenge, but I wouldn’t say it’s impossible.”
England plays France and then Papua New Guinea and must have huge wins in both matches to be a chance of making the semis.
Perhaps their best chance of winning a World Cup in the future starts with accepting the NRL’s rescue offer.

Leave a Reply